Federal Court Blocks Sale of Apache Oak Flat Land

​A federal court has blocked the government from transferring Oak Flat to a foreign-owned mining company, preserving the sacred Apache site while the U.S. Supreme Court considers whether to hear the case. The ruling is a powerful rebuke of the federal rush to transfer the land, which Western Apaches consider a portal to the Creator and the center of their religious life.
 
Judge Steven P. Logan concluded that “there is no close question in this matter,” finding it “abundantly clear that the balance of equities ‘tips sharply’ in Plaintiff’s favor.” He emphasized that the Apaches face “a likelihood of irreparable harm should the transfer proceed” and that the case presents “serious questions on the merits that warrant the Supreme Court’s careful scrutiny.”
 
Oak Flat, which sits within Arizona’s Tonto National Forest, has been central to Apache religion for centuries. For 70 years, it has been protected from mining, until a 2014 defense bill provision set the stage for its transfer to Resolution Copper, a subsidiary of a multinational firm partially owned by a Chinese corporation.
 
If the mine goes forward, the Apache will forever lose their ability to perform ceremonies tied to the land. Resolution Copper plans to turn Oak Flat into a two-mile-wide, 1,100-foot-deep crater. That devastation would be irreversible, a loss equal in scale to dynamiting the Vatican or using the stones of the Wailing Wall as a quarry.
 
Dr. Wendsler Nosie Sr. of Apache Stronghold responded bluntly: “The federal government and Resolution Copper have put Oak Flat on death row – they are racing to destroy our spiritual lifeblood and erase our religious traditions forever.”
 
The injunction prohibits the federal government from publishing its environmental report or finalizing the land transfer until the Supreme Court either denies review or issues a final ruling. That decision halts Resolution Copper’s plans to turn Oak Flat into a massive copper mine.
 
The court rejected the argument that Apache rituals could simply be relocated, stating it was “disinclined to minimize the importance of Oak Flat to the Apache’s belief system.” As previously noted by the court in 2021, the mine would “close off a portal to the Creator forever and will completely devastate the Western Apaches’ spiritual lifeblood.”
 
Judge Logan also dismissed the mining company’s claims about financial harm, noting they had invested in the land years before Congress authorized the transfer and did so “voluntarily.” In contrast, the Apaches risk losing access not just to land, but to their religious future: “They cannot choose to practice their religion at all once their sacred religious site is completely ‘obliterated,’” as one dissenting judge previously wrote.
 
Oak Flat is more than a legal fight. It’s a test of whether the U.S. government will honor its promise of religious liberty when it matters most – not just in speech, but in action. The Apache’s sacred ground deserves the same protection any church, synagogue, or mosque would be afforded. If the Apache lose, Americans of all faiths will lose as well.

DONATE & HELP US PROTECT YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS