Free Speech in Public Spaces – Why Olivier v. City of Brandon Matters

The United States Supreme Court building.

​Gabriel Olivier is an evangelical Christian who regularly preaches to passersby in a public park outside a public amphitheater in the city of Brandon, Mississippi. The city recognized Olivier’s right to speak, but told him he had to stay in a “protest area” far from people heading to the event center.
 
When Olivier approached pedestrians, he was confronted by police. When he explained to the local chief of police that he had a constitutional right to speak, he was arrested for his trouble and charged under a city ordinance. The U.S. Supreme Court will soon hear arguments on Olivier’s claim that the city ordinance violated his First and Fourteenth Amendment rights.
 
At its heart, this is classic forum law: Sidewalks, parks, and other public spaces have long been recognized as traditional fora for speech. But a procedural hurdle is at play as well: the question of whether Olivier should even get his day in court.
 
In Heck v. Humphrey, the Supreme Court held that when a plaintiff seeks restitution from state and local governments for violations of her constitutional rights, she must show that any related conviction or sentence related to that violation has been reversed, expunged, or declared invalid before suing. The Fifth Circuit held that Heck prevented Olivier from proceeding because he was convicted, pled nolo contendere, paid a fine, and chose to file a civil rights lawsuit rather than appeal his conviction.
 
Now the Supreme Court is set to determine if Olivier can bypass Heck and proceed to challenge the ordinance, or whether the procedural bar will remain, denying the merits question and leaving the city free to regulate speech.
 
If Olivier can get past this hurdle, he will have a strong case. The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, for example, has repeatedly upheld the rights of citizens to speak freely on the grounds of the U.S. Capitol, rejecting arguments that this is a “special type of enclave” immune from the guarantees of the First Amendment. Surely the prime section of a public park near an event center in Brandon, Mississippi, is subject to the same principle. Local governments often manage sidewalks, parks, plazas, and other public spaces that communities expect to remain open as fora for free speech. Consigning speakers away from intended listeners is not a reasonable restriction.
 
This case gives the High Court a chance to clarify the rules that allow citizens to challenge local restrictions on their constitutional rights. And, for a Court that has not been shy about protecting speech, it is a chance to recognize that in public parks, the roots of the First Amendment run deep.

DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS