Michigan’s Proposal 2 Threatens Independent Journalists and the Subscribers Who Support Them10/27/2026
Michigan’s Proposal 2 threatens to make the price of covering a public debate a possible three-month stretch in jail and the forced disclosure of news subscribers’ personal information to the state. Writing in The Wall Street Journal, independent journalist Dave Bondy warns that the initiative reaches far beyond its advertised restrictions on contributions from monopoly utilities and government contractors. The proposal defines “electioneering communications” to include public communications that reference a clearly identifiable candidate, target the relevant electorate, and occur within 100 days of a general election or 30 days of a primary or special election. Spending more than $5,000 annually on such communications would trigger detailed reporting to the Michigan secretary of state. That language could sweep in independent reporting, podcasts, blogs, and think tanks’ analysis of public officials and their policy proposals. In fact, Proposal 2 includes no explicit media exemption in its crackdown on sources of “electioneering communications.” If it passes, Michigan’s law would breach the privacy of people paying for that reporting. Bondy warns that he might have to disclose personal information about his paying subscribers. The Mackinac Center for Public Policy, where he works, could face similar demands for private donor identities because its nonprofit news outlet covers politicians and their records. The vague language of this ballot initiative would likely subject independent journalists and think tanks to a requirement to report to the state the names, addresses, occupations, employers, and “principal places of business” of anyone who donated more than $100 for their “electioneering communication” (potentially including news, analysis, or commentary). In an age of doxing and threats to people’s livelihoods and even personal safety, the disclosure of donor and subscriber information is a serious concern. Protect The 1st is challenging similar dangers in Alaska, where policy research became grounds for demanding a think tank’s donor lists. As we told the U.S. Supreme Court in an amicus brief about that case: “Privacy of association is the baseline. The injury is the chill itself.” Under Proposal 2, failure to file a required electioneering communication report within 30 days after its due date could expose the person responsible to up to three months in jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both. This brings to mind a quip by the 20th-century African dictator Idi Amin: “There is freedom of speech, but I cannot guarantee freedom after speech.” The incentives Michigan’s Proposal 2 would create are perverse. Journalists would have incentives to avoid interviewing candidates in an election season. Think tanks would feel compelled to shelve policy analyses. Subscribers and donors might choose to withdraw support rather than risk exposure. Michigan’s Proposal 2 would do more than encroach on the First Amendment. It would take a butane lighter to it. Michigan voters should protect everyone’s freedom to investigate, criticize, publish, and support those who do. Comments are closed.
|
Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
ABOUT |
ISSUES |
TAKE ACTION |
RSS Feed