Group Speech Is Free SpeechFirst Amendment controversies often center on individuals who take unpopular stands. But speech rights also protect groups – businesses, religious organizations, nonprofits, and trade associations – through which people speak and act collectively. In the Federalist Society’s recent webinar, “Corporate Speech in the Crosshairs: New Frontiers in First Amendment Law,” panelists examine how litigation, legislation, and government mandates threaten those rights. PT1st General Counsel Gene Schaerr moderates this discussion featuring PT1st President Erik Jaffe, Ryan Bangert of Alliance Defending Freedom, Darpana Sheth of the Center for Individual Rights, and Owen Yeates of the Institute for Free Speech. At approximately the 40-minute mark, Jaffe addresses the expanding use of the commercial speech doctrine – under which commercial speech generally receives less constitutional protection than political and artistic speech – to regulate corporate expression far beyond advertising. He focuses on two prominent corporate speech cases before the U.S. Supreme Court. Discussing Suncor Energy Inc. v. Boulder County Commissioners, Jaffe warns against treating companies’ contributions to public debate – including statements to Congress and public speeches – as commercial claims. Under that approach, companies could be punished not for specific claims about their products to consumers, but for wide-ranging statements about public policy and scientific questions addressed to the public and to Congress. Jaffe warns that this logic offers no clear-cut limit on the government’s ability to control speech by any for-profit entity. Jaffe underscores this point by explaining that this doctrine could even be extended to journalistic enterprises that operate for profit. “The New York Times, because it makes money off of magazines, might somehow be subject to a lower standard of [First Amendment] scrutiny,” Jaffe says, illustrating the troubling logic of this trend. “Just because people have a personal, or even a monetary interest, in selling a product” should not weaken their First Amendment protections. Jaffe also discusses Epic Games v. Apple, warning that the “insidious expansion of commercial speech” threatens to compel Apple to host competitors’ messages that conflict with its own vision and appeal to customers. Gene Schaerr noted that corporations – whether for-profit businesses, non-profits, or religious groups – are a means by which people associate to speak collectively, whether about matters of policy, philosophy, or economic interest. Corporate speech, he said, is thus “crucial to the ability of individuals to be able to exercise their First Amendment rights.” Watch this discussion to hear the legal and philosophical arguments against expanding the commercial speech doctrine. We do not surrender our freedom of speech simply because we speak together. Comments are closed.
|
Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
ABOUT |
ISSUES |
TAKE ACTION |
RSS Feed