|
Texas’ controversial Campus Protection Act (Senate Bill 2972) is becoming increasingly difficult to defend on constitutional grounds. The state’s own legal arguments have exposed its biggest weakness. During recent oral arguments before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Assistant Solicitor General Daniel Ortner acknowledged that a university policy banning all expressive activity overnight would be difficult to defend under the First Amendment. The law requires Texas public colleges and universities to restrict “expressive activity” between 10 p.m. and 8 a.m. It also imposes restrictions on invited speakers, amplified sound, and percussion during the final two weeks of an academic term. Passed in 2025 following campus protests, the legislation was presented as a way to protect campus communities and prevent disruption. It is easy to see the legitimate interest there. Public institutions of higher learning can impose reasonable, content-neutral time, place, and manner restrictions on protests. But, as the state’s attorney acknowledged, the broad language of this law reaches far beyond disruptive demonstrations. The law itself defines its target as “any speech or expressive conduct protected by the First Amendment.” This law practically begs to be kicked to the curb by courts. Would it restrict a student journalist working late? A religious study group holding an early-morning prayer service? A musical ensemble or musicians practicing on campus? An outdoor performance of Hamlet? The state’s defense rests partly on the argument that SB 2972 does not directly regulate students but instead requires universities to develop their own policies. However, as attorneys representing the students point out, the law explicitly requires universities to adopt these restrictions. The University of Texas at Dallas, for example, implemented them nearly word for word. This is precisely the constitutional problem: The First Amendment does not disappear at night or whenever university administrators find speech inconvenient. Public universities are places where debate, dissent, and the exchange of ideas should be protected, not restricted through sweeping rules that threaten constitutionally protected expression. The state’s own courtroom concession underscores the fundamental question: If the campus policies this law requires are so difficult to defend under the First Amendment, why should students have to live under them in the first place? Comments are closed.
|
Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
ABOUT |
ISSUES |
TAKE ACTION |
RSS Feed