|
Protect The First supports greater educational choice for families because it gives them the ability to express their values across generations – the ultimate fulfillment of the promise of a First Amendment society. The educational establishment, however, is dead set on reversing this trend – opposed to any challenge to the idea of a one-size-fits-all government monopoly on schools. A case in point is Jessica Grose’s New York Times column, which portrays Texas Education Freedom Accounts (TEFA) as a “billionaire” project at the expense of public schools. But her hit piece gives too little attention to the low-income families receiving assistance – and too much weight to preserving the educational establishment’s control. Grose quotes a superintendent calling Texas’s program a “billion-dollar giveaway program for the rich.” But consider the actual recipients. Mandy Drogin of the Texas Public Policy Foundation reports that “80 percent of funded TEFA students come from households at or below 200 percent of the federal poverty level.” For a family of four, that threshold is $66,000 annually. Nearly one-quarter of these students have a disability. So far, assistance from the Texas program is overwhelmingly reaching families of modest means. Grose emphasizes that roughly 70 percent of recipients previously attended private school or were homeschooled. But prior enrollment does not establish that the recipients are wealthy. Parents who sacrificed to find a suitable education should not be disqualified from help because they acted before the state did. Her funding argument also needs closer examination. Grose acknowledges that voucher appropriations come from a part of the Texas budget separate from public-school funding. She highlights a $227 million reduction in public-school funding. But districts receive less attendance-based funding when they serve fewer students – and declining enrollment reduces many costs. Families should not be forced to remain in unsuitable or even failing schools to protect district revenue. Even in this environment, Texas added $8.5 billion in public-education funding in the last legislative session. That does not settle every question about inflation or distribution, but it doesn’t match The New York Times’ story of abandonment. Grose does raise legitimate questions about disability access to private schools, the availability of placements, and financial oversight. The Texas program is young and still taking shape, with the potential for more private schools and additional seats to become available. Grose bemoans the prospect that as much as 90 percent of the vouchers will go to religious schools. Religious schools are a valuable choice for many families, allowing parents to choose an education consistent with their faith. Besides, religious schools tend to outperform public schools in academic achievement. The program’s funds can also support families choosing other types of schools. Texas cities have schools dedicated to the arts or sciences, as well as some with a progressive bent. Liberal families who object to the state’s increasingly conservative public-school curriculum can also use vouchers to pursue an education that reflects their values. The educational establishment’s resistance reflects a deeper assumption – that a government system should remain the only available option regardless of what parents want. Education policy should serve children’s futures, including when parents choose a different path from the one offered by a public school. Comments are closed.
|
Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
ABOUT |
ISSUES |
TAKE ACTION |
RSS Feed