Why the Catholic Church Is Standing Up for the Right of a “Woke” Private School to Manage Its Curriculum

We’ve chronicled many attempts by state authorities to try to force religiously oriented private schools to knock the religion out of their curricula. Maine, for example, persists in defying the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled that the state cannot exclude religious schools from a state-funded tuition program for simply being religious.

The expanding school choice movement is predicated on the belief that giving parents the choice of their school – whether a school with a religious character, or purely secular school dedicated to STEM or the arts – respects the pluralism of our society.

But parent-plaintiffs in North Carolina are flipping that script. They are suing a private school because their children were expelled after the parents led a protest over its supposedly “woke” curriculum.

Now the Roman Catholic Church, which has long gone to court to defend its right to maintain its traditional teachings, is going to court to support the right of this private school to maintain its non-traditional curriculum.

Here's a brief review of the case, which will be heard by the North Carolina Supreme Court in October:

• Unhappy with a leftward ideological shift after a new headmaster was installed at Charlotte Latin School, a private college preparatory academy, two parents started a protest movement at the school, engaging administrators and the board.

 

• Citing its “Partnership with Parents” agreement and determining that it had become impossible to have a productive working relationship with the parents in light of perceived attacks on the school’s mission, Charlotte Latin nullified the education contracts of the couple’s two children and severed ties.

 

• The parents sued the school, garnering support from 14 state and federal lawmakers, all North Carolina Republicans.

 

• The state’s Appeals Court ruled against the plaintiffs twice, first unanimously and then in a 2-1 split, affirming the trial judge’s original ruling. The parents had previously tried to bypass the Appeals Court but that move was rejected by the state Supreme Court because the petition deadline was missed.

 

• Meanwhile, the N.C. Association of Independent Schools and the Southern Association of Independent Schools filed an amicus brief with the Appeals Court on behalf of the school, writing:

 
“Private and independent schools should be permitted to shape their values and culture as they see fit. If some parents do not like the direction that they perceive a school to take, they should vote with their feet and seek a new school.”
 

• Last week, in anticipation of the state Supreme Court’s upcoming hearing, both associations filed an additional amicus brief. The Catholic Diocese of Charlotte did as well.

The diocesan brief is particularly noteworthy, going straight to heart of the matter in holding that private schools also have association rights under the First Amendment. The Diocese told the court:

“These contractual provisions are essential tools that allow religious schools to carry out their faith-based educational missions,” and enforcing them, “avoids entangling courts in religious questions and protects the constitutional autonomy of private religious schools under the Free Exercise and Establishment Clauses of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.”

We couldn’t agree more. If parents are unhappy with the ideology of their children’s private school, then it’s time to find a new school (there are 96 others in the N.C. Association of Independent Schools beyond Charlotte Latin). But if we allow litigation to shape the curricula of private schools, there will be no end to the control of curricula.
​
The genius of the First Amendment is that it guarantees choice in a free market of ideas. Matching families to schools, not legal coercion, is what the school choice movement is about.

DONATE & HELP US PROTECT YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS