Protect The 1st Foundation
  • About
    • Leadership
  • Issues
  • Scorecards
  • News
  • Take Action
    • Educational Choice for Children Act
    • PRESS Act
    • Save Oak Flat Act
  • DONATE
  • About
    • Leadership
  • Issues
  • Scorecards
  • News
  • Take Action
    • Educational Choice for Children Act
    • PRESS Act
    • Save Oak Flat Act
  • DONATE
Picture

Two Letters on a Wristband, Two Years to Vindicate Free Speech

11/10/2026

 
Picture
Pink wristbands with "XX" symbols were a form of protest during a Bow High School girls soccer game against Plymouth on September 17, 2024.
​How much protest can fit on a pink wristband? Enough, apparently, to get a father barred from his daughter’s soccer games.

As First Amendment Watch at New York University reports, New Hampshire fathers Kyle Fellers and Anthony Foote wore pink wristbands marked “XX” to a 2024 high school soccer game. The letters represented female chromosomes, expressing opposition to allowing transgender athletes to compete in girls’ sports. A transgender girl was playing for the opposing team.

How did school officials respond to this silent protest? They banned the fathers from school grounds. Fellers said he missed half of his daughter’s senior-year soccer games.

Now, after more than two years of litigation, a federal court has declared that the school district violated the plaintiffs’ First Amendment rights. The judgment entered on Thursday protects the plaintiffs’ right to silently wear the wristbands at district sporting events. The settlement provides $275,000 in attorneys’ fees and costs.

The plaintiffs, fittingly enough, will each receive $17.91, in honor of the year in which the First Amendment was ratified.

School officials argued that they had a duty to protect students from harassment. And they do. Officials could legitimately exclude spectators who harass players or disrupt a game. But this duty cannot be twisted to classify peaceful disagreement with a school’s preferred position as “harassment.”

The First Circuit had already found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their viewpoint discrimination claim. It concluded that the protest “fell short of harassment and disruption.” 

Officials should no more suppress a parent’s peaceful support for transgender athletes than silence peaceful opposition to their participation in girls’ sports. Government cannot make agreement with its own views the price of admission to a school sporting event.

That distinction protects everyone. It protects those who wear wristbands celebrating transgender and other LGBTQ people, as well as those whose bands say, “No Kings” or “Make America Great Again.”
​

The messages on other people’s bumper stickers, T-shirts, and wristbands may offend you. But free speech means tolerating disagreement, the basic ingredient of any national debate.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

The Right to Worship Is a Bipartisan Cause

11/10/2026

 
Picture
When anti-ICE protesters entered Cities Church in St. Paul, Minnesota, in January, they chanted slogans aimed at a pastor who also serves as an immigration enforcement official. Those protesters had every right to denounce federal immigration policy. By taking their protest inside during a service, they interrupted another group of Americans exercising a freedom protected by the same First Amendment. 

Now Republicans and Democrats in both chambers of Congress are working together to protect the right to worship. Republican Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas and Democratic Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan introduced the Right to Worship Act in the Senate. Republican Rep. Brad Knott of North Carolina and Democratic Rep. Tom Suozzi of New York introduced its House companion. 

Slotkin warned that attacks on houses of worship are on the rise.

In March, a gunman rammed a pickup truck into Temple Israel, a synagogue near Detroit, and opened fire. In May, gunmen killed three people at the Islamic Center of San Diego. And in Pittsburgh, the 2018 attack at the Tree of Life synagogue took 11 lives. These acts of violence underscore what is at stake when worshippers have reason to fear walking into a place of worship.

The Right to Worship Act would impose civil penalties for conduct that knowingly disrupts a scheduled service or impedes participation within 100 feet of a pedestrian or vehicle entrance. The restriction would run from one hour before the service begins to one hour after it ends. The bill directs courts to consider factors such as volume, duration, and impact when deciding whether conduct substantially interrupted a service. The content of the speaker’s message is irrelevant to that determination. Peaceful protest can continue within the zone if it leaves people free to enter and worship without substantial interruption.

Not all religious groups are backing this legislation. The Muslim Public Affairs Council and Bend the Arc: Jewish Action oppose this bill on First Amendment grounds, saying it would chill “lawful speech, peaceful assembly, and political protest, including on public sidewalks and streets.”

The concern about chilling peaceful protest deserves a serious answer. Under the bill, protesters could still hold signs or criticize a religious leader within 100 feet of an entrance, so long as their conduct leaves people free to attend and does not harass worshippers or substantially interrupt the service.

Implicit in the First Amendment is the right to freedom of association. Any group that bands together for the free exercise of religion has a First Amendment right to worship in peace.

Congress should pass this bipartisan legislation during the lame-duck session. Americans should be free to speak their minds on the sidewalk and free to gather in prayer on the other side of the door.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

SCOTUS Asks: Can Colorado Exclude Catholic Preschools by Writing a Rule They Can’t Accept?

11/9/2026

 
Picture
​At oral argument on Tuesday in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, several Supreme Court Justices appeared inclined to give Colorado’s preschool enrollment requirement tougher constitutional scrutiny than the Tenth Circuit did. At the heart of the case is how a supposedly “neutral” rule can effectively exclude religious schools from a public program available to secular schools.
 
The key question was identified by Justice Elena Kagan. She drew a distinction between Colorado’s rule – which requires participating preschools to offer equal enrollment opportunity to LGBTQ children and those with LGBTQ parents – and the Maine law the Supreme Court struck down in Carson v. Makin in 2022.
 
Maine expressly excluded schools that provided religious instruction from a tuition assistance program. Colorado’s rule, Kagan said, was not “another way to get at Catholic people.” A state legislature banning peyote, she observed, would also know that its law would burden Native American religious practices. In Carson, she said, “you can’t treat religious institutions differently.” The question, in her view, was “do you have to treat them better?” 
 
Nicholas Reaves, counsel for the challengers, replied to Justice Kagan by invoking Sherbert v. Verner (1963), in which South Carolina denied unemployment benefits to a Seventh-day Adventist who refused to work on Saturday, her faith’s Sabbath. The Court, Reaves argued, should examine the burden “from the perspective of the religious believer.” 
 
Justice Amy Coney Barrett tested Justice Kagan’s distinction. She asked Colorado’s lawyer, Helen Norton, how an express exclusion differed from a requirement the state knew would “push out those with a contrary belief.”
 
Justice Barrett pressed the point: “Even if it’s not what Colorado did here, don’t we have to think about that in deciding this case and how it will affect other programs?” In reply, Norton said that Colorado had invited religious providers into the program and sought St. Mary’s input. 
 
Justice Samuel Alito noted that the Constitution generally does not allow a government “to do indirectly what it is prohibited from doing directly.”
 
Norton agreed that discrimination “by stealth” is unconstitutional but said that foreseeing a rule’s effects does not establish discriminatory intent. Alito countered with a hypothetical. What if Colorado barred preschool teachers (who are devout Muslims) from wearing head coverings in the name of gender equality?
 
Turning back to Colorado’s enrollment rule, Alito said it had “a very severe impact on certain religions” that officials “could have anticipated.” He saw “little evidence, if any evidence” that LGBTQ couples could not find other preschools. He also cited Colorado’s recent First Amendment losses in court and asked Norton, “What should we make of all of this?” 
 
Justice Brett Kavanaugh pressed Colorado to explain how accommodating 34 Catholic preschools in a program with about 2,000 providers would harm LGBTQ families.
 
The oral argument suggested that a majority may favor tougher scrutiny of Colorado’s rule. If the Court takes that step, will it decide whether the rule survives that scrutiny or remand the case to the Tenth Circuit to answer that question?
 
A ruling is expected in 2027.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

FCC Nominees Should Commit to Stopping Censorship

11/6/2026

 
Picture
FCC Commissioner Nominee Danielle Thumann Severs
On Tuesday, Danielle Thumann Severs will appear before the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation for a hearing on her nomination to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
​
Given the FCC’s significant First Amendment abuses in recent years, we hope Members of the Committee will ask Severs whether she will commit to stopping the FCC’s weaponization of its regulatory powers to restrict broadcasters’ free speech. It would be a shame not to use this hearing as a teachable moment about protecting Americans’ First Amendment rights from agency misconduct.

Sen. Cruz has already spoken out forcefully against the FCC’s attempts to police speech. He called FCC Chairman Brendan Carr’s warning over Jimmy Kimmel “dangerous as hell.” He likened it to the threats of a gangster. Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) pressed the FCC’s general counsel on what business the agency had in policing criticisms aired by ABC. Sen. Kennedy added that the FCC was getting “into the foothills of violating the First Amendment.”

Protect The 1st hopes senators on the Commerce Committee will ask Severs, as well as any future FCC nominees, the following questions and insist on direct answers:

  • Will you pledge not to abuse the FCC’s licensing, investigative, and merger-review powers by using them as instruments of political intimidation over unfavorable news coverage, political satire, or viewpoints the FCC doesn’t like?
 
  • Do you believe that the FCC’s charge to regulate the public airwaves gives it license to regulate broadcasters’ content?
 
  • Do you believe it is appropriate to require broadcasters to submit their license renewal applications early in direct response to content that the FCC finds objectionable?
 
  • Do you agree that it is an appropriate use of the FCC’s authority to pressure a network to fire a late-night host, saying, “we can do this the easy way or the hard way”?
 
  • Do you agree with the statement that the FCC has the authority and the responsibility to ensure a “course correction” by legacy media and use its power to promote “trusted, respected news media”?
 
  • If so, whose definition of “trusted” is the standard? If Fox News is trusted by this administration, will it be legitimate for the next Democratic administration to target it as untrustworthy?

The FCC was never supposed to be the speech police. Anyone who wishes to serve as a commissioner should be willing to commit to the United States Senate – and to the American people – that they will uphold the First Amendment and work to end the weaponization of the agency against broadcasters’ free speech.

For background, see our previous comments on this issue:

  • It Is Time to Pull the Plug on the FCC – https://www.protect1st.org/news/it-is-time-to-pull-the-plug-on-the-fcc (September 8, 2026)
 
  • Sen. Kennedy to the FCC: “You’re Getting into the Foothills of Violating the First Amendment” – https://www.protect1st.org/news/sen-kennedy-to-the-fcc-youre-getting-into-the-foothills-of-violating-the-first-amendment (August 10, 2026)
 
  • PT1st Tells the FCC – You’re Not the Political Speech Police – https://www.protect1st.org/news/pt1st-tells-the-fcc-youre-not-the-political-speech-police (June 23, 2026)
 
  • FCC Pressure on The View Raises – Yet Another – Serious First Amendment Concern – https://www.protect1st.org/news/fcc-pressure-on-the-view-raises-yet-another-serious-first-amendment-concern (May 21, 2026)
 
  • Will Loper Bright Curb the FTC and FCC Speech Police? – https://www.protect1st.org/news/will-loper-bright-curb-the-ftc-and-fcc-speech-police (May 13, 2026)
 
  • FCC Chair Brendan Carr Is Paving the Way for Full-Blown Censorship Threatens to Pull Network Licenses for News Coverage – https://www.protect1st.org/news/fcc-chair-brendan-carr-is-paving-the-way-for-full-blown-censorshipthreatens-to-pull-network-licenses-for-news-coverage (March 17, 2026)

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Are Jews Driving Up the Price of Eggs? How the Law Treats Election-Season Lies

11/3/2026

 
Picture
​An election-season ad by an independent expenditure group blamed U.S. support for Israel for the high price of eggs. If the Jewish state can be blamed for the cost of a carton of eggs, can blaming Jews for tsunamis, cholera, and the botched revival of Sex and the City be far behind?

The logic of the ad – if we can dignify it as logic – is that the United States provides Israel with $3.8 billion in regular annual military assistance, including missile-defense funding. Excluding supplemental assistance, the regular annual amount represents a roughly 0.05 percent slice of the $7.4 trillion federal budget. Somehow, this spending is driving up the price of eggs.

This strained argument overlooks the inconvenient fact that the average price of a dozen Grade A large eggs, after skyrocketing to more than $6 in 2025 amid an avian flu outbreak, fell to $2.27 in September 2026.

So is this ad a lie? We think so, and we believe it is one tainted with antisemitism. But there is still a scintilla of an argument here. If federal spending creates inflationary pressure, then you can argue that anything Washington spends money on – aircraft carriers, Social Security payments, and testing gingerbread houses for their earthquake resistance – can theoretically be blamed for raising the price of food or anything else.

What about explicit election-year lies that lack even the scintilla of an argument? Can an out-and-out lie be prosecuted as a crime?

Consider the case of Xavier Alvarez, who in a public water district meeting in California said, “I am a retired Marine of 25 years. I retired in the year 2001. Back in 1987, I was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor.” Alvarez, in fact, was only eligible for Liar of the Year. He had not served in the U.S. Marine Corps and had never been awarded any military commendation.

Alvarez was prosecuted under the Stolen Valor Act, which criminalized such false claims. In United States v. Alvarez (2012), the U.S. Supreme Court struck down that federal law. That decision rejected the proposition that false statements and outright lies are not protected by the First Amendment.

Though Alvarez was not an election case, its implication for campaigns is clear: The government cannot simply declare political lies a category of unprotected speech. However, fraud, defamation, and other legally actionable falsehoods remain subject to their own rules.

False factual claims about a candidate – including deceptive deepfakes and fabricated allegations about the candidate’s personal life – can support a defamation lawsuit. Under the constitutional standard established in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (1964) and subsequent cases, candidates must prove “actual malice” by “clear and convincing evidence” – meaning the speaker knew that the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth. Personal hostility alone is not enough.

There is one clear area in which an election lie is prosecutable. Deliberately deceiving people about when, where, or how to vote – for example, falsely announcing that due to inclement weather Tuesday’s election has been postponed to Wednesday – can cross into criminal voter suppression.
​

The First Amendment leaves us with a decidedly imperfect defense against political lies. The best response to lies is, as always, the truth – with a defiant dash of chutzpah.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Texas’ Own Lawyer Raises Serious Questions About Campus Speech Law

11/2/2026

 
Picture
Texas’ controversial Campus Protection Act (Senate Bill 2972) is becoming increasingly difficult to defend on constitutional grounds. The state’s own legal arguments have exposed its biggest weakness.

During recent oral arguments before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Assistant Solicitor General Daniel Ortner acknowledged that a university policy banning all expressive activity overnight would be difficult to defend under the First Amendment.

The law requires Texas public colleges and universities to restrict “expressive activity” between 10 p.m. and 8 a.m. It also imposes restrictions on invited speakers, amplified sound, and percussion during the final two weeks of an academic term.

Passed in 2025 following campus protests, the legislation was presented as a way to protect campus communities and prevent disruption. It is easy to see the legitimate interest there. Public institutions of higher learning can impose reasonable, content-neutral time, place, and manner restrictions on protests. But, as the state’s attorney acknowledged, the broad language of this law reaches far beyond disruptive demonstrations.

The law itself defines its target as “any speech or expressive conduct protected by the First Amendment.” This law practically begs to be kicked to the curb by courts.

Would it restrict a student journalist working late? A religious study group holding an early-morning prayer service? A musical ensemble or musicians practicing on campus? An outdoor performance of Hamlet?

The state’s defense rests partly on the argument that SB 2972 does not directly regulate students but instead requires universities to develop their own policies. However, as attorneys representing the students point out, the law explicitly requires universities to adopt these restrictions. The University of Texas at Dallas, for example, implemented them nearly word for word.

This is precisely the constitutional problem: The First Amendment does not disappear at night or whenever university administrators find speech inconvenient.

Public universities are places where debate, dissent, and the exchange of ideas should be protected, not restricted through sweeping rules that threaten constitutionally protected expression.

The state’s own courtroom concession underscores the fundamental question: If the campus policies this law requires are so difficult to defend under the First Amendment, why should students have to live under them in the first place?

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Vermont’s Religious School Exclusion Is Bigotry Behind a Friendly Mask

10/30/2026

 
Picture
Honestly, we’re not out to discriminate against you.
It is unfortunate that our new law excludes individuals who happen to be your exact height, have your birthday, and live at your home address. But trust us, this is nothing personal.
This is the dismaying situation facing religious schools in Vermont, disqualified by eligibility rules from a state tuition assistance program available to other private schools.
State Sen. Scott Beck, a Republican, says that the new eligibility requirements were never aimed at excluding religious schools. Somehow, it just worked out that way. A new federal lawsuit, Bishop v. Saunders, is challenging that assertion. The parent-plaintiffs in that case, represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom, are asking: If a state cannot constitutionally exclude religious schools from a public benefit, can it rewrite the eligibility rules to accomplish the same result?
As Alliance Defending Freedom explains, Vermont’s Town Tuition Program helps students in districts that do not operate public schools for some or all grades to attend private schools chosen by their parents. After court decisions forced Vermont to admit religious schools, the state enacted Act 73 in July 2025. According to ADF, its requirements disqualify all fifteen previously eligible religious schools, while forty-five secular private schools remain eligible.
How do you discriminate without discriminating?
The law conditions eligibility on location, minimum average class sizes, and whether at least 25 percent of a school’s enrollment received public tuition funding in 2023–2024. That last requirement is troublingly exact: Religious schools had only recently gained access to the program after years of exclusion, and had a short time to build publicly funded enrollment before the benchmark year. Vermont is effectively using the consequences of its past discrimination to justify renewed exclusion.
A law need not contain the word “religion” to raise serious religious liberty concerns. Otherwise, constitutional protections would become drafting exercises: Remove the forbidden label, retain the exclusion, and declare the problem solved.
Governments have the authority to establish legitimate educational standards. But courts should examine whether those standards serve educational needs or function as carefully selected barriers against participation by schools because of their religious character. Such discrimination violates the First Amendment. The total exclusion of religious schools certainly warrants close scrutiny by a federal court.
Religious liberty for Vermont families means little if government can answer a constitutional defeat by tailoring a bespoke policy that happens to fit the same discriminatory cut.
Protect The 1st supports the families challenging this policy. Parents should be able to choose an education consistent with their faith without officials manipulating eligibility rules to close the door.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

What a UK Teen’s Arrest for Ridiculing a Politician Tells Us About America

10/29/2026

 
Picture
Now-deleted image of Wolverhampton Tory councillor Simon Bennett, sporting AI-generated bunny ears, whiskers, and teeth, as posted by UK 15-year-old Fraser on Facebook.
​The early 20th century writer H.L. Mencken is remembered as the “Sage of Baltimore.” Perhaps a better sobriquet would be “the Baltimore Belittler.”

Consider how Mencken skewered the presidential rhetoric of Warren Gamaliel Harding, which he dubbed “Gamalielese.” In one of his most memorable essays, Mencken wrote of Harding’s speeches:

“It reminds me of a string of wet sponges; it reminds me of tattered washing on the line; it reminds me of stale bean soup, of college yells, of dogs barking idiotically through endless nights. It is so bad that a sort of grandeur creeps into it. It drags itself out of the dark abysm (I was about to write abscess!) of pish, and crawls insanely up the topmost pinnacle of posh. It is rumble and bumble. It is flap and doodle. It is balder and dash.”

Mencken’s ridicule was merciless. But Harding did not have Mencken arrested. If anything, Harding was notably brave in defense of civil liberties. He commuted the prison sentence Eugene Debs, a Socialist presidential candidate who had received ten years in prison for the “crime” of delivering an anti-war speech during World War One.

In the internet age, critics of politicians fling vitriol laced with obscenities. Increasingly, they resort to using deepfake AI technology to make parodic imagery.

In this country, Americans remember President Harry Truman’s quip that “if you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.” We hold fast to the First Amendment, which guarantees our right to criticize our leaders – fairly or unfairly, gently or harshly. Anyone stepping into the political arena today knows that they are in for a fair amount of tough, even cruel, criticism. Strong leaders shrug it off and stick to their message.

At a time when there are calls from the American left and right to use concerns about “hate speech” and “disinformation” to control or punish speech, we get an object lesson about what life would be like without the First Amendment.

In the UK, a 15-year-old boy known as Fraser ridiculed a local politician, Simon Bennett, who serves on the Wolverhampton city council.

Fraser posted an altered image of Bennett with rabbit ears, with the caption, “Nibble … nibble … crunch … crunch Can you hear it? That’s the sound of a rabbit devouring the last remaining shreds of Wolverhampton Conservatives’ credibility.”

Fraser also took Bennett to task for wearing shorts and a T-shirt to a council meeting. When Bennett showed up at another meeting in a suit, Fraser expressed relief that Bennett “was not looking like a rent boy” – Brit for a male prostitute.

Officialdom responded as if Fraser had phoned in a phony bomb threat to city hall. No fewer than four officers showed up at the teen’s home to arrest him. He was taken to the police station, fingerprinted, given a mugshot, and interrogated about his social media posts and stance toward Bennett. Fraser’s lawyers were told that his comments could be the basis for charging him with a “hate crime.”

As Britain, Germany, and other European nations move toward censorship – and administrations of both parties try to crack down on speech – we have more reason than ever to cherish our First Amendment. It is our essential protector – our backstop – that keeps the speech police at bay. In Tennessee, retired police officer Larry Bushart, who spent 37 days in jail over a Facebook meme, secured an $835,000 settlement after suing county officials for violating his constitutional rights.

The First Amendment does not prevent abuses, but it gives us a powerful means to fight back.
As for Simon Bennett, poor wittle wabbit, barely noticed posts by a teenager are now splashed across newspapers and news sites around the world.
​
Someone give that man a carrot!

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Michigan’s Proposal 2 Threatens Independent Journalists and the Subscribers Who Support Them

10/27/2026

 
Picture
​Michigan’s Proposal 2 threatens to make the price of covering a public debate a possible three-month stretch in jail and the forced disclosure of news subscribers’ personal information to the state.

Writing in The Wall Street Journal, independent journalist Dave Bondy warns that the initiative reaches far beyond its advertised restrictions on contributions from monopoly utilities and government contractors.

The proposal defines “electioneering communications” to include public communications that reference a clearly identifiable candidate, target the relevant electorate, and occur within 100 days of a general election or 30 days of a primary or special election. Spending more than $5,000 annually on such communications would trigger detailed reporting to the Michigan secretary of state.

That language could sweep in independent reporting, podcasts, blogs, and think tanks’ analysis of public officials and their policy proposals. In fact, Proposal 2 includes no explicit media exemption in its crackdown on sources of “electioneering communications.”

If it passes, Michigan’s law would breach the privacy of people paying for that reporting. Bondy warns that he might have to disclose personal information about his paying subscribers. The Mackinac Center for Public Policy, where he works, could face similar demands for private donor identities because its nonprofit news outlet covers politicians and their records.

The vague language of this ballot initiative would likely subject independent journalists and think tanks to a requirement to report to the state the names, addresses, occupations, employers, and “principal places of business” of anyone who donated more than $100 for their “electioneering communication” (potentially including news, analysis, or commentary). In an age of doxing and threats to people’s livelihoods and even personal safety, the disclosure of donor and subscriber information is a serious concern.

Protect The 1st is challenging similar dangers in Alaska, where policy research became grounds for demanding a think tank’s donor lists. As we told the U.S. Supreme Court in an amicus brief about that case: “Privacy of association is the baseline. The injury is the chill itself.”

Under Proposal 2, failure to file a required electioneering communication report within 30 days after its due date could expose the person responsible to up to three months in jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both.

This brings to mind a quip by the 20th-century African dictator Idi Amin: “There is freedom of speech, but I cannot guarantee freedom after speech.”

The incentives Michigan’s Proposal 2 would create are perverse. Journalists would have incentives to avoid interviewing candidates in an election season. Think tanks would feel compelled to shelve policy analyses. Subscribers and donors might choose to withdraw support rather than risk exposure.
​

Michigan’s Proposal 2 would do more than encroach on the First Amendment. It would take a butane lighter to it. Michigan voters should protect everyone’s freedom to investigate, criticize, publish, and support those who do.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Judge Kyle Duncan: Who Decides How Much “Hate” Is Too Much?

10/27/2026

 
Picture
Giving government the power to punish “hate speech” means giving someone the power to decide which opinions Americans may express. Who gets that authority? And what happens when those wielding it regard your beliefs as hateful?

Judge Kyle Duncan of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit addressed those questions in his October 21 Antonin Scalia Lecture, “Hate Has a Home Here,” hosted by Advancing American Freedom and the Meese Institute for the Rule of Law.

His answer to whether American governments can constitutionally punish people for uttering hate speech was “categorically ‘no.’”

Judge Duncan knows something about the impulse to silence unwelcome views. He revisited his harrowing experience at Stanford Law School, where loud, obscene heckling by menacing students prevented him from delivering his invited talk. When he sought help from administrators, a dean instead took the podium and spoke in Judge Duncan’s stead – to denounce him. After Stanford Law School Dean Jenny Martinez subsequently apologized for this egregious violation of free speech principles, masked students made her walk a gauntlet of hostile protest.

Duncan cited a subsequent Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) survey in which more than one-third of responding Stanford law students said that using physical violence to stop a campus speech was acceptable. He said:

“Let’s not sugar-coat it: these findings are disgraceful. No one who believes these things should ever graduate from law school or be permitted to practice law … Even if these students showed up at Stanford predisposed to be little Maoists, it is Stanford’s responsibility to convince them otherwise – to teach them that their instincts about free speech are completely out of step with American traditions.”

The broader question is what happens when the impulse to suppress offensive ideas becomes government policy. Duncan confronted the strongest emotional argument for such laws:

“It is of course true that much of the speech traditionally denominated ‘hate speech’ is in fact worthless. What possible value to society is it to have antisemites chanting ‘Kill the Jews’ or Klansmen marching around in white robes and spewing racial epithets? Not much. So why not have ‘hate speech’ laws? At least we could be spared from that trash! This is no doubt why, at certain times, large segments of the American public say they are in favor of hate speech laws.”

Then came the problem for those who espouse this view:

“I think that they have not thought the matter through, however. For if you have a hate speech law, you will have to have someone to apply it. And that person – presumably a judge, but maybe an agency bureaucrat – will have to assess how much ‘hate’ is too much?”

We would add that censorship, once allowed, is a weapon that can be used against anyone. And censorship always begets more censorship. Postwar German law, understandably enough, outlawed promotion of Nazism and the display of the swastika. Today, Section 188 of the German Criminal Code makes it a crime to insult “someone involved in the popular political life.” This is a perfect illustration of censorship’s tendency toward mission creep, leading to outrages like prosecuting people for making fun of politicians.

As Duncan explained, constitutional protection for offensive expression is compatible with laws addressing threats, fraud, defamation, and other narrowly defined categories of unprotected speech. But offense alone cannot give government a license to censor.

Defending that distinction requires both sound law and a public willing to uphold it. Duncan closed with an admonition worth remembering:
​

“The temptation is to ask the law to step in and clean things up. We should resist it.”

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

“Paid For By the U.S. Government” Shouldn’t Mean Political Propaganda

10/26/2026

 
Picture
When we file our taxes, we may pause to think of how our money pays for battleships, Social Security payments, moon launches, and nutritional benefits for low-income Americans. We don’t, generally, imagine that we’re paying for government-sponsored commercials to tell us what to think.

Concerns about government-funded propaganda motivated Sen. Mike Lee’s Charlie Kirk Act, introduced to restore restrictions on domestic dissemination of government-funded overseas broadcasting. As Sen. Lee put it, “Americans can figure out the truth for themselves without government telling them what to believe.”

The government does pay to provide news and other content to foreign markets, bringing critical information to audiences living under censorship regimes. For decades, the Voice of America and other official media have enhanced America’s reputation and shed light where it is needed. Federal law restricted domestic dissemination of government-funded media intended for foreign audiences.

In the internet age this strict separation became impossible. To adapt this system to our times, the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act, signed by President Obama in 2013, expanded Americans’ access to overseas programming. It did not authorize government broadcasters to target Americans with propaganda. Nevertheless, abuses followed the liberalization of this law.

As
Courthouse News reports, The New York Times revealed in 2018 that Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty used Facebook advertisements to target Americans with its stories. A House Foreign Affairs Committee report that year identified at least 860 instances of such advertising by the federal broadcasting agency.

These abuses illustrate the concerns behind Sen. Lee’s bill. Democrats now have reason to share his concern.

You may have recently seen an ad in which the president declares, “America will never be a communist country,” accompanied by a chorus singing “love me.” Another pairs Mount Rushmore with presidential boasts. A third recycles campaign imagery and warns of “the final battle.”

Americans watching from their couches and recliners had reason to sit up when they saw the ads’ closing disclosure: “Paid for by the U.S. Government.”

According to Shane Goldmacher and Maggie Haberman of The New York Times, more than $10 million had already been spent airing these ads when the administration announced that President Trump’s super PAC would cover future costs.

Yet White House officials say there is no plan to reimburse taxpayers for those millions already spent on these ads.
​

Lee’s bill addresses overseas broadcasting. Congress should also confront taxpayer-funded self-promotion. The misuse of public funds for what many would view as propaganda is now a problem that should concern both parties. When the dust settles after the election, there should be a bipartisan solution.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Does the First Amendment Protect the Ramaswamy “Mother of All Attack Ads”?

10/26/2026

 
Picture
Vivek Ramaswamy speaking with attendees at the 2022 AmericaFest at the Phoenix Convention Center in Phoenix, Arizona. PHOTO CREDIT: Gage Skidmore/FLICKR
​By now you’ve probably seen stories about the negative ad from Vivek Ramaswamy’s Ohio gubernatorial campaign against his opponent, Democrat Amy Acton. In that ad, Donna Arthur, Acton’s mother, says that her daughter has “a serious problem – she is a liar and she lies about her past.”

The story behind the ad is that Amy Acton was removed from her mother’s care – they haven’t spoken in nearly 50 years – after her stepfather was accused of raping Acton when she was 12 years old.

Acton told WSYX of Columbus that she had testified about her abuse before a grand jury, and that “my mother and my stepfather were arrested living in a tent and all of that is record.”

After a Mahoning County grand jury charged Acton’s stepfather with rape, her stepfather skipped town on bond and hid out in another state as a fugitive with her mother.

Acton notes that “there had been 11 other children who had been molested, including my stepfather’s own.”

While Ramaswamy doubles down in defense of his ad and criticism intensifies, the controversy offers us a teachable moment about the First Amendment: Does constitutional protection for political speech shield a campaign from defamation liability?

The First Amendment imposes an exceptionally strong barrier against prior restraints, particularly for political speech.

But could Ramaswamy or his campaign face civil liability? Political speech receives strong constitutional protection, but that protection does not automatically foreclose a successful defamation claim. In a landmark U.S. Supreme Court case, New York Times v. Sullivan (1964), the Court established a rigorous standard for any public official to prevail in a defamation case. The Court later extended that standard to include candidates for public office.

That is largely a good thing. Politics is a blood sport. If every insult and exaggeration became fodder for defamation lawsuits, the courts would be clogged, and public discourse would be chilled.

Yet Sullivan allows a public official to prevail by proving that the defendant published a defamatory falsehood with “actual malice” – knowledge of its falsity or reckless disregard for whether it was false.

Under that tight standard, former Republican presidential candidate Barry Goldwater nevertheless prevailed in his lawsuit in the 1960s against Fact magazine, which portrayed Goldwater as psychologically unfit for the presidency. Evidence showed that the magazine had manipulated psychiatrists’ responses and published unsupported accusations.

Ramaswamy’s lawyers would no doubt say they were just airing a claim made by Acton’s mother. But her accusation – that Acton lied about her family’s dire living conditions – asks us to ignore a court’s removal of Amy Acton from her mother’s custody.

The broad statements in the ad also imply that the rape charge against her stepfather was a lie. To accept that implication, one must ignore the stepfather’s long and troubled history of rape accusations, and the fact that he fled justice after being indicted by a grand jury on the charge of raping his stepdaughter.

Even evidence that the ad was false would not, by itself, establish actual malice. Acton would have to prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that the campaign knew that the defamatory claim was false or published it while entertaining serious doubts about its truth.

While Acton might indeed be able to clear that high bar, she seems to have elected not to descend into the often-destructive briar patch of litigation. She is responding to such dubious speech with her own counter speech.
​
Whether or not a lawsuit follows, Ohio voters will have the chance to deliver their own verdict on this ad.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMEnDMENT RIGHTS

The Value a Jewish Democrat Sees in School Choice Scholarships

10/22/2026

 
Picture
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul
​Protect The 1st has applauded New York Gov. Kathy Hochul and Colorado Gov. Jared Polis for recognizing that they can support both public schools and expanded educational choice. As Gov. Hochul put it in supporting participation in the new federal tax-credit scholarship program: “I’m not going to leave money on the table when it could help our kids.”

Now Rep. Jared Moskowitz of Florida is urging his fellow Democrats to embrace these scholarships, which will promote school choice beginning in 2027. He bases his powerful argument not just on expanding parents’ educational options, but also on protecting Jewish identity and children’s safety.

Writing in The Wall Street Journal, Moskowitz begins with the same bipartisan appeal as Gov. Hochul:

“I have always supported strong public schools, and I still do. But supporting public education and enhancing parents’ ability to seek a safe school for their child aren’t mutually exclusive.”

His perspective is painfully personal. Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, where a gunman murdered 17 students and staff in 2018, is Moskowitz’s alma mater. The shooter had etched swastikas on his ammunition magazines – a chilling detail for Moskowitz, whose grandmother escaped Berlin on the Kindertransport, and great-grandparents were murdered at Auschwitz. In 2024, authorities intercepted an armed man whose antisemitic manifesto named Moskowitz as a target.

Rep. Moskowitz writes:

“My wife and I are raising two boys, and we think about these risks every time we drop them off at school.”

Beginning in 2027, the federal tax-credit scholarship program will help eligible families afford educational options, including Jewish day schools. But states must opt in for families attending schools in those states to benefit. So far, only 30 states have opted in.

“At a time when Jewish families have serious concerns about antisemitism and security, partisan disagreements over education policy shouldn’t keep them from the resources that would let them make the best decisions for their children.”
​

Protect The 1st supports school choice because we see families’ ability to pass on their values and traditions to the next generation as a quintessential expression of First Amendment freedom. Moskowitz highlights another urgent reason to include religious schools: While sustaining Jewish identity, these schools offer refuge to a community under siege.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
Button Text

Protecting Those Who Minister to Our Military

10/20/2026

 
Picture
In December 1944, Gen. George Patton gave his chief chaplain, James O’Neill, an unusual assignment: compose a prayer for good weather. (Spoiler alert – the skies cleared.) When the Battle of the Bulge was won, that “Weather Prayer” became one of the war’s most enduring stories – a reminder that even a hard-driving general recognized the importance of spiritual support.

The American military chaplaincy was already nearly 170 years old. At George Washington’s request, the Continental Congress authorized chaplains for the Army’s regiments on July 29, 1775, just six weeks after the Army’s establishment. During the Revolution, 218 chaplains served the cause of independence.

They began a tradition of courage as well as comfort. Army chaplains have served in every major American conflict. Across the military nine chaplains have received the Medal of Honor, including Korean War Army chaplain Emil Kapaun. Their mission reaches from the foxhole to the family back home: nurture the living, care for the wounded, and honor the fallen.

That history deserves more than anniversary celebrations. It deserves legal protection.

The Military Chaplains Modernization Act of 2026, introduced by Sen. James Lankford (R-OK), would codify chaplains’ purpose, duties, and professional qualifications while protecting their ability to minister according to their faith. Joining him are Sens. Katie Britt (R-AL), Mike Rounds (R-SD), Chuck Grassley (R-IA), and Kevin Cramer (R-ND). Rep. Keith Self (R-TX) leads the House effort.

“Chaplains serve because they are called to it,” Lankford said.

Britt emphasized their contribution: “Military chaplains serve a unique and important role in our armed forces, providing spiritual guidance to our men and women in uniform.”

The bill would prohibit assignments that violate chaplains’ sincerely held religious beliefs and protect them from retaliation, including denied promotions and reprimands. It would also codify the ranks and advisory roles of Chiefs and Deputy Chiefs of Chaplains, preserving their place in senior military leadership.

Rank matters in an institution organized around command. Chaplains need the standing to counsel military leaders and advocate for service members’ religious freedom. A strong military chaplaincy helps American service members perform their duties under extraordinary pressure and danger.
​

Does this bill have a prayer of passage? Rep. Self reports that he successfully led an effort to attach the bill to the National Defense Authorization Act, the must-pass defense budget.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR RELIGIOUS FREEDOM

Will AI Regulations Restrict Free Speech?

10/20/2026

 
Picture
​If AI were a prescription pharmaceutical with its own television ad, it might depict happy families running across a sun-drenched park while the announcer says: “AI is a transformative technology that will cure age-old scourges of humanity, increase productivity to generate social wealth for all, and keep our country at the forefront of global innovation.”

Then, the announcer adopts a lower tone of voice and issues a staccato burst of warnings: “Serious side effects might lead to catastrophic unemployment for graphic designers, paralegals, data entry personnel, interpreters, bookkeepers and accountants, and more. Other side effects could include the extinction of the human race.”

This, more or less, has been the messaging of senior AI researchers and developers, including several CEOs. One prominent Cassandra is Evan Hubinger, Anthropic’s alignment science lead, who estimates a greater than 10 percent chance that artificial intelligence will lead to the end of the human race within the next decade.

Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln…

We agree that now is the time to debate the various ways the power of self-improving superintelligence could go wrong. Among the most urgent concerns are preventing the misuse of AI to develop powerful bioweapons or to craft devastating cyberattacks.

When it comes to regulations concerning speech, however, the greater threat is from proposed rules, not the technology. This came to mind when former Microsoft CEO Bill Gates recently included “disinformation” and deepfakes among AI’s most serious threats.

Gates is not wrong. A shrewdly made deepfake could derail an election, spook the stock market, or provoke a national security emergency.

Yet as AI guardrails are developed, we must ensure that someone doesn’t slip in measures that restrict the free expression of opinions, especially criticism or ridicule of the political and corporate powers-that-be (the very people who will be writing the rules).

The Future of Free Speech analyzed the policies of the largest generative AI companies and criticized their “precautionary, regulate-first” approach. The organization found that “providers seem to have opted for a sanitized model straight away, ignoring or minimizing freedom of expression considerations.”

Under pressure from government and subservient corporations, AI can easily achieve what no other likely form of suppression can effectively achieve – stealthy prior restraint. The most insidious form of censorship is not the excision of ideas. It is the disappearance of facts and ideas we never knew existed.

If this seems like a stretch, consider:

  • The now-defunct Global Engagement Center, a State Department entity that gave large grants to an NGO that distributed blacklists of conservative media outlets to advertisers.
 
  • The deployment of more than 80 FBI agents to secretly “jawbone” social media platforms into removing or shadow-banning posts disfavored by the government.
 
  • The issuance of executive orders targeting law firms for punishment because of the political activity of former members.

Do we trust these same elites to craft policies that can differentiate “disinformation” from opinions they don’t like?

The same question applies to proposals to regulate images. It is one thing to generate a false AI-produced image of, say, a politician engaged in a sex act on the eve of an election. It is quite something else to satirize President Donald Trump standing next to a giant cannon on the White House lawn to fire deportees into the air, or Gov. Gavin Newsom deploying a giant can of Febreze over San Francisco to mask the city’s “poo smell.”

AI regulations must never conflate fraud with satire and thereby abridge the right of Americans to ridicule their elected representatives.

Cato scholar David Inserra wrote in 2024 that “a risk-based approach acknowledges that most AI applications, especially those involving speech and expression, should be considered innocent until proven guilty.”

We agree with Inserra’s assessment that the risk of AI disinformation is best handled by existing law, the organic development of social norms and best practices, competition in the marketplace, third-party certification, and AI literacy.
​
So regulate AI to reduce risks to human life and the economy. But fears of existential catastrophe must not become a justification for restricting free speech.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FREE SPEECH RIGHTS

Free Speech Week Burns Brighter This Year

10/19/2026

 
Picture
​If you light a candle and set it on a table in the sunlight, its flame will almost disappear. If you wait until evening, the candle’s flame will become radiant and necessary.

You could say the same of Free Speech Week, observed Oct. 19-25 this year, and sponsored by the Media Institute and the National Association of Broadcasters Education Foundation.

For years, this annual celebration of free speech has reminded Americans that our First Amendment rights promote a vibrant, pluralistic society. These organizations have kept this civic flame burning, even when it attracted little notice. As the sky darkens, its light is needed more than ever.

Why is the sky suddenly darkening? Across the nation, we see a loss of commitment to – or even basic understanding of – the value of free speech. This erosion is evident in the actions of officials from both political parties, from Washington, DC, to small towns.

At its most basic level, many Americans have simply lost the thread on free speech – failing to understand that this principle applies to people they don’t like who say things that make them angry.
  • A survey of college students by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) found that almost 70 percent of students responded that shouting down a campus speaker is acceptable under some conditions. Thirty percent said using violence to stop a campus speech is sometimes acceptable.
 
  • New York ordered that state’s largest charter-school network not to release its Advanced Placement exam results for inclusion in the national education rankings published by U.S. News & World Report. Many believe that the New York State Education Commissioner is engaging in this censorship to avoid embarrassment from a comparison between the performance of public schools and charter schools.
 
  • The Federal Communications Commission required eight ABC-owned local stations to submit license-renewal applications ahead of schedule, giving them just 30 days to prepare. Disney’s lawsuit alleges that the order was retaliation for constitutionally protected programming. It included pressure to fire late-night host Jimmy Kimmel for his commentary. FCC Chairman Brendan Carr warned ABC: “We can do this the easy way or the hard way.”
 
  • The State of Florida is predicating an investigation of the editorial decisions of The New York Times on the state pension fund’s equity holdings in that media organization.
 
  • The city of University Heights, Ohio, issued a cease-and-desist order to stop a Jewish man from holding weekly gatherings for a small group of men for quiet, contemplative prayer.
 
  • A Hofstra University professor is fighting for his career and reputation against an official investigation by that university because he criticized another professor’s presentation as a “word salad.”
 
  • The U.S. Justice Department dispatched four federal agents to the homes of journalists with subpoenas requiring those journalists to testify before a federal grand jury about their sources.

Fortunately, the First Amendment allows us to be vocal in defense of free speech.

If you are an educator, the Free Speech Week website offers lesson plans for discussing free speech in the classroom.

You can adopt the Free Speech Love badge for your social media profile.

Or you can email your Members of Congress to urge them to pass the Protect Reporters from Exploitive State Spying (PRESS) Act, a bipartisan bill that would create a federal shield for the confidential notes and sources of reporters.

The PRESS Act would include narrow exceptions and would not grant reporters blanket protection. But it would help protect confidential sources from government intimidation, with federal agents playing the heavy at reporters’ doorsteps.
​
We don’t have to wait until the flame of free speech gutters out. We can brighten it by making the best daily use of our right to speak out.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FREE SPEECH RIGHTS

If the State Owns Your License Plate, Does It Own Your Message?

10/18/2026

 
Picture
A Virginia driver has turned an acronym on a license plate into a First Amendment question that could now reach the U.S. Supreme Court: When the government allows us to use public property to express ourselves, can it then restrict or edit our messages?

Curtis M. Whateley put this question to the test when he ordered a personalized license plate reading “FTP&ATF” in 2023. The first letter of that acronym stands for the “F” word, yielding the message “F the Police and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.” (Unsolicited advice: While a license plate’s message should have no bearing on official actions, in the real world this is not an ideal look for anyone concerned about being pulled over by the police.)

Virginia moved to recall the plate after receiving an anonymous complaint. The state cited restrictions on vulgarity and messages encouraging violence. This being America, Whateley sued.

In court, the state argued that personalized plates are government speech in part because the state itself owns the physical license plate. This interpretation would place Whateley’s salute to law enforcement outside the protections of the First Amendment.

A federal district court agreed. But on July 31, a unanimous Fourth Circuit panel held that the personalized messages are private speech and returned the case for further review. Whateley thus won the right to have his claim evaluated under the First Amendment. That distinction matters. When the government invites citizens to express themselves, it cannot then claim ownership of their messages.

Protect The 1st made that very argument in Shurtleff v. City of Boston. Boston had permitted 284 flag-raising events on a city flagpole without rejecting an application. Then it refused a flag with an emblem that included a Christian cross. The city claimed that the flags constituted government speech, allowing officials to exclude the religious message.

Our amicus brief warned that this reasoning would let government convert permission into ownership of expression, and ownership into a license to censor. The Supreme Court agreed, unanimously ruling against Boston in 2022. The city’s operation of the program made the flag raisings a form of private expression, meaning that the exclusion of a religious viewpoint violated the Free Speech Clause. Providing a public platform did not make every participant a government spokesperson.

License plates present an additional complication. In 2015, the Supreme Court held that specialty-plate designs in Texas constituted government speech, allowing Texas to reject a design featuring a Confederate flag. But a driver’s personally chosen combination of characters raises different questions. The Fourth Circuit recognized that distinction. According to Reason’s August report, Virginia said it would seek Supreme Court review.

We don’t have to admire Whateley’s sentiment to recognize the danger of Virginia’s position. The same principle that protects a Christian flag from exclusion protects an abrasive criticism of law enforcement.

When government opens a public venue to private expression – whether a flagpole or a government-owned license plate – it must administer that venue on viewpoint-neutral terms. It cannot exclude messages simply because officials are offended by that viewpoint.
​
Perhaps the deeper issue is the government’s decision to provide a public frame for private speech. If officials fear that allowing a message implies endorsing it, then perhaps the best answer is not to offer the platform at all.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FREE SPEECH RIGHTS

Gov. Hochul Steps Up for Students – Gov. Shapiro, Your Turn

10/13/2026

 

​Pennsylvania’s Governor Should Quit Hiding and Join His Neighbor on Scholarship Tax Credits

Picture
New York Governor Kathy Hochul
Congratulations to New York Gov. Kathy Hochul for recognizing that educational opportunity should transcend partisan politics. Her decision to move forward with the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit deserves applause – and action from neighboring Pennsylvania.

In her October 9 statement, Hochul delivers a refreshingly practical message:

“I’m not going to leave money on the table when it could help our kids.”

After reviewing the federal regulations, she concludes that the program can bring millions of additional dollars to New York families without reducing public-school funding or drawing from state or local budgets. She also reports commitments from business leaders to support public-school students through the program.

That is leadership. Earlier this year, Gov. Jared Polis of Colorado demonstrated that a Democratic governor could support public education and give families more educational options. Hochul also understands that these goals can reinforce each other.

Beginning January 1, 2027, this program offers taxpayers a federal tax credit for qualifying donations to scholarship-granting organizations in participating states. Scholarships can support private-school tuition as well as tutoring, technology, and special-needs services benefiting public-school students. Before families can take advantage of this program, states must opt-in for donations to go to qualifying scholarship organizations.

So where is Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania?

Protect The 1st urged Shapiro in March to connect families in the Keystone State with this opportunity. We renewed that appeal this month. Yet at his October 7 debate, Shapiro remained uncommitted, saying he was “digesting” the federal rules.

Careful review is reasonable. But Pennsylvania families have been left hanging for months. Gov. Hochul has reviewed the rules and explained why participation serves her constituents. Pennsylvania families deserve the same clarity.

Protect The 1st supports educational choice as a First Amendment issue because it enables parents to pass their values from one generation to the next. Whether families choose a religious school, a secular school, or extra help for a child attending public school, they deserve the means to pursue an education that fits their children’s needs.
​

Gov. Shapiro, join your neighbor. Bring Pennsylvania families into the program.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US ADVOCATE FOR YOUR SCHOOL CHOICE RIGHTS

Did the FBI Turn a Bullhorn into Grounds for an Investigation?

10/13/2026

 
Picture
FBI Director Kash Patel (Left) & U.S. President Donald Trump (Right)
​A former FBI intelligence official is accusing the Bureau of caving to official pressure to investigate protesters solely for exercising their First Amendment rights.

In February 2025, volunteers in Southern California used bullhorns, sirens, and social media to alert neighbors to immigration-enforcement operations. As KPBS reported, organizers described their activities as nonviolent efforts to inform residents and remind them of their rights. A former ICE official warned that these tactics could endanger officers and approach the line separating lawful activity from unlawful interference.

Where we draw that line matters. So does whether anyone actually crossed it.

According to Jill Fields, a former supervisory intelligence analyst in the FBI’s Los Angeles field office, her squad was ordered to conduct “pre-assessment checks” on protesters shown on TikTok using bullhorns in the city of Alhambra. Fields says the squad lacked evidence of a crime and that FBI policy prohibited opening investigations solely on the basis of protected First Amendment activity.

Official annoyance over a protest is no substitute for evidence. If Fields’ account is accurate, the apparent sequence is chilling: identify the speakers, demand arrests, and send investigators looking for a justification.

Fields also alleges that administration officials demanded an investigation into the activities of anti-ICE protesters outside a federal building in California. She says she faced retaliation for raising constitutional concerns and ultimately resigned. These remain allegations, but they warrant independent scrutiny.

The administration denies wrongdoing. The White House says the investigations concerned criminal conduct, while the Justice Department and FBI defend their responsibility to investigate potential federal offenses. “Assaulting and obstructing law enforcement is a crime,” a White House spokeswoman said.

Of course it is. But that statement leaves the central question unanswered: What evidence linked these particular protesters to assault, unlawful obstruction, or another federal crime?

Calling speech “obstruction” does not establish that it is criminal. Nor does frustration with protesters establish grounds to investigate them. The government must distinguish peaceful opposition from unlawful conduct, even when that opposition complicates enforcement or embarrasses officialdom.
​

An FBI investigation can chill dissent long before anyone is charged. Americans must be free to question, criticize, and peacefully oppose government policy – even noisily – without wondering whether a viral video will put them in the crosshairs of a federal investigation.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FREE SPEECH RIGHTS

What The New York Times Doesn’t Get: Texas Vouchers Help Low-Income Families

10/12/2026

 
Picture
Protect The First supports greater educational choice for families because it gives them the ability to express their values across generations – the ultimate fulfillment of the promise of a First Amendment society. The educational establishment, however, is dead set on reversing this trend – opposed to any challenge to the idea of a one-size-fits-all government monopoly on schools.

A case in point is Jessica Grose’s New York Times column, which portrays Texas Education Freedom Accounts (TEFA) as a “billionaire” project at the expense of public schools. But her hit piece gives too little attention to the low-income families receiving assistance – and too much weight to preserving the educational establishment’s control.

Grose quotes a superintendent calling Texas’s program a “billion-dollar giveaway program for the rich.” But consider the actual recipients.

Mandy Drogin of the Texas Public Policy Foundation reports that “80 percent of funded TEFA students come from households at or below 200 percent of the federal poverty level.” For a family of four, that threshold is $66,000 annually. Nearly one-quarter of these students have a disability. So far, assistance from the Texas program is overwhelmingly reaching families of modest means.

Grose emphasizes that roughly 70 percent of recipients previously attended private school or were homeschooled. But prior enrollment does not establish that the recipients are wealthy. Parents who sacrificed to find a suitable education should not be disqualified from help because they acted before the state did.

Her funding argument also needs closer examination. Grose acknowledges that voucher appropriations come from a part of the Texas budget separate from public-school funding. She highlights a $227 million reduction in public-school funding. But districts receive less attendance-based funding when they serve fewer students – and declining enrollment reduces many costs. Families should not be forced to remain in unsuitable or even failing schools to protect district revenue.

Even in this environment, Texas added $8.5 billion in public-education funding in the last legislative session. That does not settle every question about inflation or distribution, but it doesn’t match The New York Times’ story of abandonment.

Grose does raise legitimate questions about disability access to private schools, the availability of placements, and financial oversight. The Texas program is young and still taking shape, with the potential for more private schools and additional seats to become available.

Grose bemoans the prospect that as much as 90 percent of the vouchers will go to religious schools. Religious schools are a valuable choice for many families, allowing parents to choose an education consistent with their faith. Besides, religious schools tend to outperform public schools in academic achievement. The program’s funds can also support families choosing other types of schools.

Texas cities have schools dedicated to the arts or sciences, as well as some with a progressive bent. Liberal families who object to the state’s increasingly conservative public-school curriculum can also use vouchers to pursue an education that reflects their values.
​

The educational establishment’s resistance reflects a deeper assumption – that a government system should remain the only available option regardless of what parents want. Education policy should serve children’s futures, including when parents choose a different path from the one offered by a public school.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US PROTECT YOUR SCHOOL CHOICE RIGHTS

PT1st’s Erik Jaffe Examines Efforts to Weaken First Amendment Protections for Businesses

10/12/2026

 

Group Speech Is Free Speech

Picture
First Amendment controversies often center on individuals who take unpopular stands. But speech rights also protect groups – businesses, religious organizations, nonprofits, and trade associations – through which people speak and act collectively.

In the Federalist Society’s recent webinar, “Corporate Speech in the Crosshairs: New Frontiers in First Amendment Law,” panelists examine how litigation, legislation, and government mandates threaten those rights. PT1st General Counsel Gene Schaerr moderates this discussion featuring PT1st President Erik Jaffe, Ryan Bangert of Alliance Defending Freedom, Darpana Sheth of the Center for Individual Rights, and Owen Yeates of the Institute for Free Speech.

At approximately the 40-minute mark, Jaffe addresses the expanding use of the commercial speech doctrine – under which commercial speech generally receives less constitutional protection than political and artistic speech – to regulate corporate expression far beyond advertising. He focuses on two prominent corporate speech cases before the U.S. Supreme Court.

Discussing Suncor Energy Inc. v. Boulder County Commissioners, Jaffe warns against treating companies’ contributions to public debate – including statements to Congress and public speeches – as commercial claims.

Under that approach, companies could be punished not for specific claims about their products to consumers, but for wide-ranging statements about public policy and scientific questions addressed to the public and to Congress. Jaffe warns that this logic offers no clear-cut limit on the government’s ability to control speech by any for-profit entity.

Jaffe underscores this point by explaining that this doctrine could even be extended to journalistic enterprises that operate for profit.

“The New York Times, because it makes money off of magazines, might somehow be subject to a lower standard of [First Amendment] scrutiny,” Jaffe says, illustrating the troubling logic of this trend. “Just because people have a personal, or even a monetary interest, in selling a product” should not weaken their First Amendment protections.

Jaffe also discusses Epic Games v. Apple, warning that the “insidious expansion of commercial speech” threatens to compel Apple to host competitors’ messages that conflict with its own vision and appeal to customers.

Gene Schaerr noted that corporations – whether for-profit businesses, non-profits, or religious groups – are a means by which people associate to speak collectively, whether about matters of policy, philosophy, or economic interest. Corporate speech, he said, is thus “crucial to the ability of individuals to be able to exercise their First Amendment rights.”
​

Watch this discussion to hear the legal and philosophical arguments against expanding the commercial speech doctrine. We do not surrender our freedom of speech simply because we speak together.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US PROTECT YOUR FREE SPEECH RIGHTS

PT1st Congratulates Eugene Volokh on Prestigious Free Speech Prize

10/6/2026

 

Our Senior Legal Advisor Honored for Advancing First Amendment Freedoms

Picture
Eugene Volokh
Protect The 1st warmly congratulates our Senior Legal Advisor, Eugene Volokh, on his selection as the 2026 recipient of the Richard D. McLellan Prize for Advancing Free Speech and Expression. Administered by the Russell Kirk Center, the $50,000 prize recognizes exceptional contributions to protecting and advancing freedom of expression.

A senior fellow at the Hoover Institution and professor emeritus at UCLA School of Law, Eugene has helped generations of students, lawyers, and judges understand the First Amendment. His scholarship has been cited in more than 400 court opinions, including in twelve Supreme Court opinions. Eugene has also brought his expertise directly to the defense of the First Amendment in more than 40 appellate cases, including representing PT1st in an en banc proceeding of the Washington, D.C. Court of Appeals.

As founder and editor-in-chief of the Journal of Free Speech Law and founder of The Volokh Conspiracy, Eugene has made legal analysis accessible far beyond the classroom.

“Little wonder the prize jury selected him unanimously,” said Gene Schaerr, PT1st general counsel. “Eugene is a powerful champion of free speech. It’s rare for a leading academic to also be a talented popularizer who can explain to the public the commonsense concerns behind esoteric legal principles.”

For PT1st, this honor celebrates a principle central to our mission – the conviction that freedom of speech protects everyone, including those whose views provoke disagreement or discomfort. Preserving that freedom requires clear thinking, principled advocacy, and the willingness to defend difficult cases.

Eugene’s career exemplifies that commitment. We are proud to work alongside him and delighted to see his contributions receive this well-deserved recognition.
​

Congratulations, Eugene!

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FREEDOM OF SPEECH

Muslim Doctors Challenge Illinois Law that Would Force Them to Refer Patients to Suicide Providers

10/6/2026

 
Picture
​We recently reported on the vigorous protests and legal action by the Catholic Church to protect caregiving nuns from being forced by New York State to refer patients to suicide providers. The Church objects to the Medical Aid in Dying Act that would compel nuns to assist their elderly patients in meeting the requirements for assisted suicide and refer them to clinics willing to supply the lethal drugs.
 
As one state after another attempts to force religious people to violate their faith, states are discovering that opposition comes from more than just Christians.
 
In Illinois, four Muslim doctors recently filed suit to block the state’s enforcement of provisions that would force these doctors to help patients end their lives. The physicians also assert that the law’s provisions amount to a gag order that could punish them for encouraging patients to consider life-affirming treatments over assisted suicide.   
 
For these physicians, this is nothing less than an official command to commit a grave sin. The Quran teaches that “whoever saves a life, it will be as if they saved all of humanity.” And those who unjustly take lives? The Quran says it will be as if they killed all of humanity.
 
The lawsuit, brought in federal court on behalf of these physicians by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, takes aim at Illinois’ End-of-Life Options for Terminally Ill Patients Act.
 
Proponents of the law say it gives terminally ill patients “the option to seek medication to peacefully end their lives on their own terms in consultation with physicians.” Gov. JB Pritzker’s office maintains that healthcare professionals “are not under any duty to participate in the provision of aid-in-dying and are not subject to criminal or civil liability” for refusing to provide assisted suicide.
 
It is true that this law exempts physicians from being forced to prescribe the lethal drugs. Yet the physicians assert that doctors who refuse to provide referrals could still be slapped with heavy fines and have their licenses revoked.
 
Many Muslims are, understandably, alarmed. Ismail Royer of the Religious Freedom Institute testified in March at a hearing of the White House’s Religious Liberty Commission (RLC) about the fears of Muslim practitioners who worry that they will have to choose between practicing medicine and staying true to their faith.
 
“As the effective date of the Illinois assisted suicide law approached, I knew the physicians I’d interviewed in preparation for my RLC testimony were deeply worried,” Royer said. 
 
By some estimates, nearly 5 percent of physicians in America are Muslims. They should not be forced to violate their core beliefs, whether by referring people to providers of assisted suicide or accepting a gag order that could punish them for suggesting less extreme alternatives.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR RELIGIOUS FREEDOM

Blue-State Governors: Take the Scholarship Money Educational Opportunity Should Not Be Another Partisan Issue

10/5/2026

 
Picture
Earlier this year, Oregon Gov. Tina Kotek rejected tens of millions of dollars in scholarships for Oregon children under the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit with this revealing explanation:

“I simply cannot trust that any education policy coming from Trump’s White House is in the best interest of Oregon’s kids.”

Really, does everything have to be about Trump? Starting in 2027, this program will allow federal taxpayers to claim a federal income-tax credit of up to $1,700 for donations to approved scholarship organizations. Gov. Kotek, take note: these scholarships not only support private-school tuition, but also pay for expenses that benefit public-school students, such as tutoring, technology, and special-needs services.

Thirty states have opted in, and New York has committed to join. Four have declared they will decline. Democratic governors Kathy Hochul of New York, who has expressed conditional acceptance, and Jared Polis of Colorado have chosen a more practical course than Kotek. Gov. Polis calls the program “free money.” These Democratic governors understand that they can oppose, denounce, and counter President Trump policies while accepting this opportunity to help children.

These Democrats also understand that acceptance will not divert state appropriations from public schools. These are private donations supported by a federal tax credit. Governors remain responsible for their own public-school budgets.

Even the liberal Boston Globe editorial board is urging Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey to participate. Its “Take the money, governor” editorial makes the point plainly: “it also lets the same pot of money improve public schools.” For Massachusetts, the pot of money for scholarships to hand out to Bay State families could reach $459 million if enough taxpayers participate.

The Globe notes that some worry that the program could disproportionately benefit wealthier districts. But nonprofits and school districts serving low-income students can help counter this by creating scholarship-granting organizations to support those students.

Then there is Illinois, where Gov. J.B. Pritzker is still on the fence.

The Land of Lincoln offers a roadside reminder of what refusing this opportunity might mean. The Indianapolis-based Institute for Quality Education is advertising near the state border, inviting Illinois residents to donate to Indiana’s scholarship program. Illinois taxpayers can claim the federal credit for qualifying donations there even if Gov. Pritzker keeps his state out of the program. Their money would help Indiana children while Illinois families miss out.

Gov. Pritzker should consider the embarrassment of Illinois donations supporting opportunities his own constituents cannot access in his state. Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, also undecided, should consider neighboring New York’s commitment to join.

Protect The 1st supports families’ freedom to express their First Amendment values by choosing an education consistent with their children’s needs and their convictions. Governors should put those families ahead of partisanship.
​

Fourteen states have not decided. Take the money, governors. Give your states’ children more educational opportunity.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS

Alaska Defies Supreme Court by Turning Policy Debate into a Demand for Donor Lists

10/5/2026

 

“The Injury Is the Chill Itself”

Picture
States and lower courts remain stubbornly resistant to accepting well-defined Supreme Court precedents. We see it in the unequal treatment of private religious schools, in challenges to the conscience rights of caregivers, and in efforts to evade a principle established almost 70 years ago – donor privacy is essential to protecting freedom of speech and association.

In NAACP v. Alabama (1958), the Supreme Court recognized that compelled disclosure could chill association and suppress dissent. The Court reaffirmed those protections in Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta (2021). Yet states keep demanding that nonprofit advocacy organizations that analyze policy issues and inform the public of their viewpoints identify their supporters. And some lower courts uphold these actions, refusing to apply these clear precedents.

Now the Alaska Policy Forum is asking the Supreme Court to protect it against overreach by bureaucrats in Juneau and a state supreme court that agreed with them.

Before Alaska’s November 2020 election, the Forum published and shared research, press releases, and a video criticizing ranked-choice voting. A ballot initiative proposed adopting that voting system, among other changes. But the Forum’s materials did not name the initiative.

An advocacy group nevertheless complained that the Forum had violated Alaska’s campaign-finance requirements. The Alaska Public Offices Commission agreed, and the Alaska Supreme Court upheld its decision.

The consequences reach well beyond paperwork. Alaska’s requirements include registration, reporting, and disclosure of donors’ names, addresses, occupations, and employers. Organizational donors must identify their officers and directors. Regulated speech must also identify the speaker and its top contributors, as if it were a campaign ad.

Protect The First Foundation and the John Locke Foundation have submitted a joint amicus brief supporting the Forum’s petition. Our opening makes the stakes plain:

“The petition should be granted to make clear that a State may not unmask a nonprofit’s donors merely because the organization spoke about a public-policy issue that appeared on a ballot …

“Privacy of association is the baseline. The injury is the chill itself.”

In this age of doxing and personal attacks, supporters may flee when a spotlight is thrown on them and their businesses. Prospective donors may stay away, and organizations will have an incentive to avoid controversial subjects.

Our brief also challenges the lower courts’ repeated expansion of disclosure rules governing candidate-related speech into the broader realm of public-policy debate. Alaska, like the Sixth, Ninth, and Tenth Circuits, has blurred the line, exposing anything remotely “political” to disclosure rules.

That is why we’ve joined with the John Locke Foundation to urge the U.S. Supreme Court to grant review or summarily reverse Alaska’s ruling. A think tank should not have to surrender its supporters’ privacy whenever an issue it studies reaches the ballot.

There is no longer any denying that some states are edging toward nullification – the strategy of the antebellum South to ignore national laws and precedents and set their own. It is time for the Supreme Court to show the Alaska high court that the Civil War settled this question long ago, and that when it comes to basic constitutional rights, states are not a law unto themselves.

​The best outcome would be for the U.S. Supreme Court to summarily reverse Alaska’s ruling.

    STAY UP TO DATE

Subscribe to Newsletter
DONATE & HELP US DEFEND YOUR FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS
<<Previous

    Archives

    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021

    Categories

    All
    2022 Year In Review
    2023 Year In Review
    2024 Year In Review
    2025 Year In Review
    Academic Freedom
    Amicus Briefs
    Analysis
    Artificial Intelligence
    Book Banning
    Campus Speech
    Censorship
    Congress
    Court Hearings
    Donor Privacy
    Due Process
    Executive Power
    First Amendment
    First Amendment Online
    Freedom Of Expression
    Freedom Of Press
    Freedom Of Religion
    Freedom Of Speech
    Government Ownership
    Government Transparency
    In The Media
    Journalism
    Law Enforcement
    Legal
    Legislation
    Legislative Agenda
    Letters To Congress
    Motions
    News
    Online Speech
    Opinion
    Parental Rights
    PRESS Act
    PT1 Amicus Briefs
    Save Oak Flat
    School Choice
    SCOTUS
    Section 230
    Speaking Of The First Amendment
    Supreme Court

    RSS Feed

we  the  people.

LET  YOUR  VOICE  BE  HEARD:


ABOUT

Who We Are

​Leadership

ISSUES

1st Amendment

TAKE ACTION

Donate

​Contact Us
® Copyright 2026 Protect The 1st Foundation