Protect The 1st Foundation
  • About
    • Leadership
  • Issues
  • Scorecards
  • News
  • Take Action
    • PRESS Act
    • Save Oak Flat Act
  • DONATE
  • About
    • Leadership
  • Issues
  • Scorecards
  • News
  • Take Action
    • PRESS Act
    • Save Oak Flat Act
  • DONATE
Picture

Protect The 1st Challenges Weak Standard that Allows Destruction of Religious Sacred Sites

5/20/2021

 
apache arizona ninth circuit Protect The 1st
Creator: Molly Riley | Credit: AP
​Protect The 1st recently filed an amicus brief in the Ninth Circuit supporting the Yakama Nation and the Grand Ronde Tribes following the destruction of their sacred lands. Its brief summarizes principles of religious freedom important to all communities of faith.
 
In the brief, Protect The 1st argued that a highway enlargement project that destroyed the tribes’ sacred lands substantially burdened their rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and the Free Exercise Clause.
 
For centuries, these Native Americans have revered a scenic site in central Oregon. Ignoring their concerns, the government cut down trees, scattered and removed an ancient altar, unearthed gravesites and killed off medicinal plants. A federal district judge held that the destruction of sacred land did not substantially burden these tribes’ religious exercise under RFRA because it neither deprived the tribal members of government benefits nor subjected them to civil or criminal penalties.
If the Ninth Circuit’s narrow standard for what qualifies as a substantial burden is affirmed, no sacred place will be safe. The rights of these Native Americans are shared by all.

​​“It’s too late to protect the sacred land of the Yakama Nation and the Grand Ronde Tribes,” said Bob Goodlatte, former House Judiciary Chairman and now Senior Policy Advisor for Protect The 1st. “We can at least persuade the Ninth Circuit to review its narrow standard of what constitutes a burden on the free exercise of religion. This doctrine is being used by lower courts to hold that the annihilation of places of worship are somehow not ‘substantial’ burdens.”
 
Protect The 1st was joined in its brief by the Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty, the Sikh Coalition, and the Anglican Church in North America Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and the Chaplaincy.
 
“If the Ninth Circuit’s narrow standard for what qualifies as a substantial burden is allowed to stand, no sacred place will be safe,” Goodlatte said. “The rights of these Native Americans are shared by all.”
 
Protect The 1st is supporting the Apache tribes in a similar challenge to an 11th-hour deal in Congress slipped into the 2015 defense authorization bill to trade their sacred land to a foreign mining company. If that company is allowed to mine copper, the sacred lands of the Apache will be reduced to a two-mile wide sinkhole a thousand feet deep.
 
“What we’ve seen in Oregon is the tragic result of ambiguity around a single modifier – the word ‘substantial’ – and the inability of courts to see that the destruction of a religion’s sacred site is about as ‘substantial’ as a burden can be,” Goodlatte said. “We hope this case prompts the court to impose a more robust standard that no court can ignore.
 
“Above all, we are working to see that what happened to the Yakama Nation and the Grand Ronde Tribes does not happen to the Apache tribes of Arizona.”

Comments are closed.

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021

    Categories

    All
    2022 Year In Review
    Amicus Briefs
    Analysis
    Campus Speech
    Court Hearings
    Donor Privacy
    First Amendment
    First Amendment Online
    Freedom Of Press
    Freedom Of Religion
    Freedom Of Speech
    In The Media
    Journalism
    Law Enforcement
    Legal
    Legislative Agenda
    Motions
    News
    Opinion
    PRESS Act
    PT1 Amicus Briefs
    Save Oak Flat
    School Choice
    SCOTUS
    Section 230
    Supreme Court

    RSS Feed

we  the  people.

LET  YOUR  VOICE  BE  HEARD:


ABOUT

Who We Are

​Leadership

ISSUES

1st Amendment

TAKE ACTION

Donate

​Contact Us
® Copyright 2023 Protect The 1st Foundation